PETER'S POLAR PARLOR
Six Decades. One Tasty Tradition.
3345 MILTON AVE • FAIRMOUNT
HOURS
SUNDAY - THURSDAY
11:30am to 9:30pm
FRIDAY + SATURDAY
11:30am to 10pm
60 Years of Peter's!
Peters Polar Parlor was built in 1969 by Peter DeVoria who ran the business until it was sold in 1986 to Lou Flask. It was acquired by Peter Haun in 2001, who ran it until he retired in 2023. Enter the Penizotto family, who also owns and operates both Big Dip of North Syracuse and Sno-Top of Manlius. Sisters Jacquie and Allison along with help from the rest of the Penizotto family manage day-today operations, carrying on the torch of this beloved Syracuse treasure.
THE FLAVORS
CLICK TO EXPAND
Soft Ice Cream
Vanilla + Chocolate Twist
Chocolate + Peanut Butter Twist
Additional flavors Available Seasonally:
Maple • Black Raspberry • Pumpkin • Vanilla
​*DAIRY FREE* Dole Whip also Available!
Hard Ice Cream
Vanilla • Chocolate • Cookie Dough • Mint Chocolate Chip • Cookies & Cream • Pistachio • Espresso Chocolate Chip
Graham Slam • Lemon Ice • Blue Raspberry Ice • Peanut Butter Chocolate • No-Sugar-Added Vanilla with Raspberry Swirl
Strawberry • Rainbow Sherbet • Sea Salt Caramel • Cotton Candy Confetti • Maple Walnut • Chocolate Peanut Butter
Specialty Cones
Cake Cone
Plain Waffle
Fancy Waffle
Plain Sugar Cone
Fancy Sugar Cone
Gluten Free Cone
Chocolate Cone
Sundaes
Grasshopper - Mint Chocolate Chip with Hot Fudge and Oreo
Black Forest - Vanilla with Cherry Topping, Hot Fudge and a Homemade Brownie
Chocolate Peanut Butter Overload - Peanut Butter and Chocolate Twist with Peanut Butter Topping, Hot Fudge and your choice of Reese’s cups or pieces or both.
Snickers - Sea Salt Caramel Ice Cream with Caramel, Hot Fudge and Snickers
Turtle - Vanilla with Hot Fudge, Caramel and Pecans
Mexican - Vanilla with Chocolate Syrup and Spanish Nuts
Dirt - Vanilla with Hot Fudge, Oreo and Gummy Worms
Smore - Graham Slam Ice Cream with Hot Fudge and Marshmallow
Banana Splits
"Make Your Own" Sundae Toppings:
Hot Fudge • Caramel • Peanut Butter • Strawberry • Raspberry • Pineapple • Peanuts • Spanish Nuts • Pecans • Peanut Butter Cups • Cookie Dough • Butterfinger • Vanilla Cake Batter • Heath Bar • Oreo • Snickers • Reese's Pieces • Homemade Brownie • Gummy Worms • Marshmallow
Big Wheels
BUY 4 • GET 2 FREE!
Vanilla • Chocolate • Peanut Butter • Black Raspberry
GET 'EM TWISTED!
Chocolate • Vanilla • Twist
Vanilla / Black Raspberry • Twist
Chocolate / Peanut Butter • Twist
Pumpkin Big Wheels COMING THIS FALL
Milkshakes
Classic: Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry
Fruity: Cherry • Banana • Cherry • Pineapple • Raspberry
Rich: Maple • Coffee • Birthday Cake
Modern: Oreo • Peanut Butter • Chocolate Peanut Butter
...or any of our Hard Flavors!
Flurries
M&M's
Peanut Butter Cups
Cookie Dough
Butterfinger
Vanilla Cake Batter
Heath Bar
Oreo
Snickers
Reese's Pieces
Classic Drinks
Slushies + Juicy Freezes
Blue Raspberry • Cherry • Lemon Lime • Grape • Orange
Ice Cream Soda
Banana • Cherry • Raspberry • Chocolate • Vanilla • Strawberry
Soft Drinks + Floats
Coke • Diet Coke • Rootbeer • Sprite • Lemonade • Fruit Punch
Smoothie
Strawberry • Banana • Raspberry • Pineapple • Cherry
Cafe Cooler Frappés
French Vanilla • Mocha • Coffee • Caramel
Frozen Drinks
Blue Moon - Lemon Ice with Blue Raspberry Flavoring blended with Sprite
Cactus Cooler - Lemon Ice with Lemon Lime Flavoring blended with Sprite
Dole Whip Blast - Dole Whip Flavor of the week blended with Sprite
Sherbet Slush - Rainbow Sherbet blended with Fruit Punch or Pink Lemonade
Shark Attack - Blue Raspberry Slush with Vanilla Ice Cream, Cherry and a Gummy Shark
Frozen Lemonade - Lemon ice blended with Pink Lemonade
Specialty Treats
Dole Whip Parfait
dole whip with soft serve vanilla
Trash Cans
soft serve vanilla, chocolate sauce, crushed oreos, whipped cream, candy eyes, and gummy worms in a take-home toy can
Glaciers
soft serve vanilla + your favorite slush
Shirley Temple Float
soft serve vanilla + lemon lime soda with maraschino cherry juice and a cherry
Shark Attack
blue raspberry slush + soft serve vanilla with gummy sharks and cherry juice
Frozen Chocolate-Covered Banana
Grab Bag
a pair of mystery treats in a bag
Extras
Sprinkles: Rainbow • Chocolate • Krunch Kote
Dips: Chocolate • Blue Raspberry • Peanut Butter • Cherry
Doggie Treat: Kiddie bowl of vanilla + a dog biscuit.
Hofmann's Hot Dogs proudly served here!
BE THE FIRST!
Know when special flavors drop
Contact Us
FREQUENTLY ASKED
QUESTIONS
Do you take credit cards?
Absolutely.
What are your specialties?
Dole Whip parfaits, Trash cans, Glaciers, and more... absolute rarities and some one-of a kind treats! For a full list, and descriptions of each, browse our menu under "specialty treats' --you're sure to find something that sparks your interest :)
Do you make ice cream pies?
We sure do! Just give us a call 24 hours in advance and we'll make anything that strikes your fancy, custom made to order!
Do you offer any vegan options?
We always have at least one vegan ice cream option available! (chocolate chunk, cookie dough chip, or classic cookie) --Plus... Italian ice, frozen chocolate bananas, slushies as well as our Dole Whip flavors, Dole Whip blast, Dole Whip glacier, Blue moon, Cactus cooler and Frozen Lemonade!
